Six Days In Fallujah, a game about the bloodiest fight of the Iraq War which was announced in 2009, and later put on ice, has been revived. 

Highwire Games, a new studio led by former Bungie Executive VP Peter Tamte, will be bringing back the title some 12-years later. With such sensitive materials, one would think there would be a delicate response to the politics at play and context to the portrayal of real-world events, but sadly that is not the case here.

The game centers around the (second) battle for Fallujah in 2004, a city that had been overtaken by infamous terrorist Abu Musab al-Zarqawi. American forces attempted to regain power of the city, leading to the bloodiest battle of the Iraq War. The fight caused the deaths of about 100 Americans and nearly 1,000 Iraqi civilians.

In an interview about the game, Mr. Tamte gave his thoughts on how the politics of the games should be perceived, telling Polygon “For us as a team, it is really about helping players understand the complexity of urban combat. It’s about the experiences of that individual that is now there because of political decisions. And we do want to show how choices that are made by policymakers affect the choices that [a Marine] needs to make on the battlefield. Just as that [Marine] cannot second-guess the choices by the policymakers, we’re not trying to make a political commentary about whether or not the war itself was a good or a bad idea.”

Marine Sergeant Eddie Garcia: Left - being interviewed for Six Days in Faluja, center - game render, right -  photo from military service.

Here is the problem: Highwire Games is making a game about the Iraq War, but wants it to not be political. The mere act of making the game, a game about possibly the biggest failure in American foreign policy, makes it political. It’s an incredibly obvious point, one that the general gaming audience would see but Tamte clearly failed to realize. The invasion of Iraq itself was a war crime, and romanticizing any moment of it is either an act of pure stupidity or intentional negligence.

Twitter went ablaze with opinions on the revival of this game, some of which were worth noting:

If Six Days In Fallujah was about a fictional war, Tamte’s answer would read a bit differently. But these are actual events that happened in recent history, and the game will only serve to justify the war crimes that took place there. The story of Fallujah cannot be told without the murder of civilians, and the aftermath that came from the crimes committed by the American military.